Network Working Group                                   L. Peter Deutsch
RFC # 446                                               SRI
NIC # 14068                                             January 25, 1973


        Proposal to consider a Network Program Resource Notebook


The recent requests by Jean Iseli of MITRE for information about all
resources of type X available on the network (where X=macro processors,
data management systems, and electromagnetic wave analysis programs)
lead me to suggest that the NIC be a repository for the replies.

    Since the exchange of knowledge and techniques (not to mention
    programs) is a central motivating factor in the development of the
    ARPANET, it seems only reasonable that we begin to systematize the
    process now that someone (MITRE and the government agencies on whose
    behalf it is acting) feels there is enough information to be worth
    collecting.

    Obviously, the network community should be in a position to profit
    from such compilation at least as much as outside agencies.

The NIC already has catalog and keyword capabilities for the Journal and
a large index of computer-related documents which are not on-line.  I
would presume that extending this system to include programs and
documentation would not be a major task and would probably bring
immediate payoffs in terms of increased effectiveness of research sites.

This suggestion does not touch on the important larger issue, namely,
what obligations does the network community have to act as a service and
information resource to the outside world (government agencies in
particular) as opposed to its presumed major function of learning about
how to build and use computer networks and its actual major function of
research in many areas of computing which have nothing to do with
networks at all.

    I feel that the confusion between the ARPANET as a service network
    and the ARPANET as an experiment in the line of network research,
    and the frustrations and communication failures resulting from
    superimposing network responsibilities on top of existing research
    projects, have not received adequate contemplation by the network
    community.








Deutsch                                                      PAGE 1 


RFC 446            Network Program Resource Notebook        January 1973


    I also feel that the ambiguous status of the network has lead to a
    sharp division between research/maintenance sites and government
    agency user sites, a situation which only can exacerbate my own
    feeling that to some extent the former are being exploited for non-
    research purposes in a manner that has been fairly rare in the
    history or ARPA/IPT.










       [ This RFC was put into machine readable form for entry ]
       [ into the online RFC archives by Alex McKenzie with    ]
       [ support from GTE, formerly BBN Corp.             9/99 ]
































Deutsch                                                      PAGE 2 



Proposal to consider a network program resource notebook

RFC TOTAL SIZE: 3053 bytes
PUBLICATION DATE: Thursday, February 24th, 2000
LEGAL RIGHTS: The IETF Trust (see BCP 78)